top of page

Are You Making These 3 Common Boundary Setting Mistakes? (Hint: It’s Why You’re Still Exhausted)

Apr 22
7 min read

If you’ve been working on how to stop people pleasing, you’ve probably heard: “Just set boundaries.”

And you’re like… Cool. I tried. Why am I MORE tired now?

If boundary setting feels exhausting, it’s usually not because you’re doing it “wrong.” It’s because you’re doing it the way most people pleasers do it, meaning you’re still over-functioning, still managing other people’s emotions, and still quietly drifting into self abandonment… just with a new vocabulary word.

This post is for the woman in midlife who’s doing a lot of inner work and still finds herself:

  • saying yes when she means no

  • rewriting texts ten times so nobody gets mad

  • holding her breath when she finally speaks up

  • feeling guilty for “having needs”

  • collapsing into resentment and exhaustion anyway

Let’s make boundary setting feel less like a second job.

Why boundary setting is so exhausting for people pleasers

Here’s the truth: boundary setting for people pleasers is rarely just about a schedule or a request.

It’s about belonging.

When you’ve learned (consciously or unconsciously) that love, safety, approval, or connection comes from being “easy,” “helpful,” or “low maintenance,” then boundaries don’t feel like a neutral decision. They feel like a risk.

So instead of setting a boundary and letting it be simple, people pleasers often:

  • over-explain to prevent conflict

  • soften the message to manage someone’s feelings

  • delay until they’re already burned out

  • say it in a way that requires constant follow-up

That’s not weakness. That’s conditioning.

And we’re going to clean that up.

Midlife woman holding tangled strings, illustrating the exhaustion of boundary setting for people pleasers.

Mistake #1: Being too vague (so you don’t “sound mean”)

Vague boundaries are the most common ones I see, especially right after someone starts doing this work.

They sound like:

  • “I’m just really busy right now.”

  • “I’ll try, but I’m not sure.”

  • “I’ll let you know.”

  • “Maybe another time.”

  • “I’m going to attempt to have better boundaries…” (you can feel the wobble, right?)

Vagueness is often a sneaky form of people pleasing. It’s basically saying, “I don’t want to disappoint you, so I’m going to leave the door cracked open and hope you don’t walk through it.”

Why it makes you exhausted

Because you never truly close the loop.

  • They keep asking.

  • You keep explaining.

  • You keep feeling guilty.

  • You keep negotiating with yourself.

And your nervous system never gets to land.

What to do instead: make it clear and kind

Clear doesn’t mean harsh. Clear means clean.

Try:

  • “No, I can’t do that.”

  • “That doesn’t work for me.”

  • “I’m not available for that.”

  • “I can do X, but I can’t do Y.”

  • “I’m heading home now. I’ll talk to you tomorrow.”

If you need a simple formula, use this:

Boundary = decision + limit

  • “I’m not taking work calls after 6.”

  • “I’m not discussing that topic today.”

  • “I can’t host this year.”

Quick reframe for your brain

A boundary isn’t a debate invitation. It’s information.

If you find yourself wanting to “prove” you deserve a boundary, pause and ask:

“Am I setting a boundary… or am I asking permission to have needs?”

That question alone can shift everything.

Mistake #2: Apologizing and over-explaining (aka “making it palatable”)

This one is the classic.

It sounds like:

  • “I’m so sorry, I feel terrible, I just have a lot going on, and I know you’re probably upset, and I totally understand if you hate me…”

  • “I’m sorry, I can’t, because my kid has a thing and I haven’t slept and my mom needs me and…”

  • “I’m sorry, I know I said yes, but I didn’t realize you meant THIS weekend, and…”

People pleasers often communicate boundaries like they’re writing a legal defense.

Why it makes you exhausted

Because you’re still doing emotional labor.

You’re not just setting boundaries, you’re:

  • anticipating their reaction

  • managing their discomfort

  • trying to keep them happy

  • trying to stay “good” in their eyes

It’s exhausting because you’re doing your boundary and their boundary too.

And here’s the thing: the more you explain, the more people think it’s negotiable. Over-explaining creates an opening for:

  • debate

  • persuasion

  • guilt

  • “But I thought you said…”

  • “Just this once…”

What to do instead: keep it short (and tolerate the discomfort)

Try these scripts:

When you need to say no

  • “No, I can’t.”

  • “That won’t work for me.”

  • “I’m not available.”

When they push

  • “I hear you. My answer is still no.”

  • “I’m not discussing it further.”

  • “I’m going to stick with what I said.”

When guilt shows up

  • “It makes sense I feel guilty. I’m still allowed to have a boundary.”

A note about apologizing

Apologies are for harm, not for limits.

If you truly did something harmful, own it. But if you’re simply saying, “I’m not available,” you don’t have to apologize for being a human with energy limits.

If you want a softer tone without apologizing, use warmth:

  • “I appreciate you asking.”

  • “Thanks for thinking of me.”

  • “I love you. And the answer is no.”

Warmth is connection. Apologizing is self-erasure. Big difference.

Mistake #3: Waiting until burnout (then dropping a boundary like a bomb)

This one is so common, especially for women who have spent decades being the “reliable one.”

You hold it. You keep being nice. You keep showing up. You keep swallowing resentment.

And then one day… you snap.

Your “boundary” comes out like:

  • “I’m done. Don’t ask me for anything ever again!”

  • “I ALWAYS do everything around here!”

  • “Nobody cares what I need!”

  • “I can’t believe you’d even ask me that!”

And to be clear: that explosion usually comes from a real place. But it’s also a sign you’ve been abandoning yourself for too long.

Why it makes you exhausted

Because burnout boundaries are reactive. They’re not sustainable.

When you set boundaries only after you’re depleted, you end up in a cycle:

  1. Over-give

  2. Resent

  3. Explode

  4. Feel guilty

  5. Overcompensate

  6. Repeat

That cycle is self abandonment with a rotating cast.

What to do instead: set “early” boundaries (before resentment builds)

Here’s a simple check-in question you can start using:

“If I say yes to this, will I resent it later?”

If the answer is yes, that’s your cue to pause.

Try these earlier-stage boundaries:

  • “I can help for 30 minutes, then I need to stop.”

  • “I can’t take that on this week.”

  • “I can do it, but not the way you’re asking.”

  • “I’m not available last-minute. I need more notice.”

This is how you prevent the blow-up.

The part most people miss: boundaries need follow-through

A boundary without follow-through becomes a suggestion.

If you say, “I don’t do work calls after 6,” but you answer at 8… your nervous system learns: My needs don’t matter. And the other person learns: She doesn’t mean it.

Follow-through doesn’t have to be dramatic. It can be simple:

  • If they call after 6 → you don’t answer

  • If they keep texting after you said you’re done → you stop responding

  • If someone shows up late repeatedly → you start without them or you leave at the agreed time

Consequences are not punishment. They’re clarity.

Hands untying a knot, symbolizing how to stop people pleasing and break patterns of self abandonment.

The real reason boundaries feel hard: you’re not just setting a boundary, you’re breaking a pattern

If you’re thinking, “But why does this feel so intense? I’m just saying I can’t make it to brunch…”

Here’s why: for many people pleasers, boundaries poke old wiring.

For a lot of women in midlife, people pleasing started as a smart survival strategy:

  • keep the peace

  • stay emotionally safe

  • avoid criticism

  • earn love through usefulness

  • minimize your needs to reduce stress in the room

This is where April’s theme comes in: Childhood Emotional Neglect.

Not always in the dramatic, obvious way. Sometimes it looked like:

  • your emotions were dismissed (“You’re fine.” “Stop crying.”)

  • you were praised for being “mature” and “easy”

  • you learned not to need too much

  • you became the helper, the fixer, the peacekeeper

  • you got attention when you performed, not when you felt

And if nobody taught you that your needs mattered, then boundary setting now feels like trying to speak a language you were never taught.

So if you’re exhausted, it doesn’t mean you’re failing. It means you’re in a rewiring season.

A simple boundary checklist (so you don’t spiral)

Before you send the text, have the conversation, or decide what to do, run it through this:

1) Is it clear?

Can the other person tell exactly what you mean?

Bad: “I’ll try.” Better: “I can’t.” / “I’m available Saturday, not Friday.”

2) Is it clean (not padded with guilt)?

Can you remove the apology/essay and still feel grounded?

Try: “That won’t work for me.” (Full sentence.)

3) Is it early (not after resentment)?

Are you addressing it at a 2/10 annoyance… or a 9/10 meltdown?

Earlier is kinder, to you and to them.

4) Is there follow-through?

What will you do if it’s ignored? (Not what they’ll do, what you will do.)

This is how you stop boundary setting from being exhausting and start making it stabilizing.

Boundary scripts for people pleasers (copy/paste friendly)

Because sometimes you just need the words.

Family

  • “I’m not discussing that today.”

  • “I’ll come for two hours, then I’m heading out.”

  • “I’m not available to host this year.”

Friends

  • “Thanks for inviting me. I’m going to pass.”

  • “I can’t do last-minute plans. I need a little notice.”

  • “I’m not up for talking about that, but I’d love to hear how work is going.”

Work

  • “I can do that by Friday, not by tomorrow.”

  • “My bandwidth is full. Which priority should I move?”

  • “I’m offline after 6. I’ll respond tomorrow.”

Partner

  • “I’m happy to talk about this, but not while we’re heated.”

  • “I need 20 minutes to reset, then I’ll come back.”

  • “I’m not okay with being spoken to like that.”

If you set boundaries and still feel guilty… you’re normal

Guilt doesn’t always mean you did something wrong. Often it means:

  • you did something new

  • you disrupted a role you’ve played forever

  • your nervous system is adjusting

  • someone else is uncomfortable and you’re used to fixing that

Guilt is information, not instruction.

You can feel guilty and keep the boundary.

Bridging into April: why this isn’t just a boundary issue

In April, we’re going to go deeper into Childhood Emotional Neglect and how it creates the adult patterns that look like:

  • chronic people pleasing

  • difficulty identifying needs

  • fear of disappointing others

  • over-responsibility

  • perfectionism

  • feeling guilty for resting

  • staying in relationships that drain you

  • living with low-grade exhaustion like it’s normal

Because when boundary setting feels impossible, it’s often not a skills problem. It’s a belonging problem.

And the good news? Skills can be learned. And belonging can be rebuilt, from the inside out.

A quick teaser: The Belonging Room (mid-May)

If you’re reading this and thinking, “Okay… I can see the patterns, but I need support actually changing them,” you’re not alone.

In mid-May, I’m opening The Belonging Room: a space for women who are done self abandoning, done performing for love, and ready to practice:

  • boundary setting without the crash afterward

  • emotional regulation when guilt spikes

  • reconnecting with needs (without shame)

  • choosing yourself in real time, in real relationships

More details are coming soon. For now, take this with you:

Your boundaries aren’t the problem. The old story that says you don’t get to have needs is the problem.

And we’re rewriting that.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page